For more than 30 years, nothing kept Tom Candela and his friends from gathering each week to play Dungeons and Dragons. But in 2020, disagreements about politics broke up their game.

Two men laughing and talking on a pier with a view of the Hudson River behind them. Michael Youssouf and Tom Candela, Memorial Park, Nyack, NY, May 13, 2025. George Pejoves for StoryCorps.

Tom was the only one who had voted for Donald Trump. He and fellow player Michael Youssouf came to StoryCorps to talk about what happened.

They spoke as part of StoryCorps’ One Small Step program which brings people together across differences – not for a debate – but to understand each other better.

Top Photo: Tom Candela and Michael Youssouf, Memorial Park, Nyack, NY, May 13, 2025. George Pejoves for StoryCorps.

Originally aired May 30, 2025 on NPR’s Morning Edition.